Showing posts with label california department of public health. Show all posts
Showing posts with label california department of public health. Show all posts

Friday, October 9, 2009

San Diego County Nursing Home Fined for Resident's Death

Fallbrook Hospital District Skilled Nursing Facility, located in San Diego County, has received the most severe penalty under California law that long-term nursing facilities can receive. An investigation by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) revealed that inadequate care had led to the death of a male nursing home resident last summer.

Fallbrook received an "AA" citation and was fined $90,000 by the CDPH. The CDPH is responsible for issuing citations and fines when nursing homes are found to be providing inadequate or negligent care of their residents. The CDPH has three different categories for citations and fines, with the "AA" citation being the harshest penalty. The categories are as follows:

- Class AA: $25,000 to $100,000 fine

- Class A: $2,000 to $20,000 fine

- Class B: $100 to $1,000 fine

According to CDPH's site, an "AA" citation is defined as "a violation that has been 'determined to have been a direct proximate cause of death of a patient or resident of a long term care facility.'" To enforce an AA citation, the CDPH must prove (1) the violation was a direct proximate cause of death and (2) the death resulted from an occurrence that the regulation was designed to prevent.

According to California Healthcare Foundation's (CHF) site, Fallbrook is located in Fallbrook city in San Diego County. The facility accepts Medicare and Medi-Cal and it has a total of 93 beds. On CHF's site, Fallbrook received a below average rating for the number of hours staff devote to each resident per day. The facility also received a below average rating for the "complaints" category, and as for the "quality of care" category, CHF noted that eight percent of Fallbrook residents spend most of their time in bed, whereas the State's average was five percent.

In this particular instance, the director of CDPH, Mark Horton, stated that Fallbrook failed to initiate a plan to prevent the resident's risk of injury. The male resident was listed as having a high risk of falling. When the resident did fall, he broke his leg and he subsequently died of complications resulting from the surgery to his leg.

Federal Nursing Home Laws

Nursing homes that participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs must comply with federal rules regarding the type of care residents should receive. Under Title 42 CFR Section 483.20, nursing homes must conduct initial and periodic assessments of each resident's functional capacity. The assessment must include a review of the resident's cognitive patterns, communication, psychosocial well-being, physical functioning, and medications among other factors.

Title 42 CFR Section 483.25 also states that each resident must receive and the nursing facility must provide "the highest practicable physical, mental, and psycho-social well-being" for residents, in accordance with the assessment of the patient's needs and plan of care. It appears that in this situation, Fallbrook failed to take the necessary measures to ensure that the resident would be safe and not susceptible to injury.

When nursing home management and staff fail to abide by federal and state rules, the risk of serious injuries and deaths of nursing home residents are considerable. It is imperative that families, who are trying to find the right nursing facility for their loved ones, research and visit facilities before making their final decision.

Unfortunately though, incidents of nursing home abuse and neglect do occur. If you or someone you know has been the victim of nursing home abuse or negligence, contact the Casiano Law Firm for a confidential consultation to discuss your case.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Medicare Releases Nursing Home Rating System

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services created a rating system for comparing nursing homes throughout the United States. The ratings are searchable through the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services website, through a Nursing Home Compare search engine. The ratings are based on three categories:

  • Health Inspections
  • Staffing
  • Quality

These three categories are each given an individual a star rating on a one to five scale. The ratings are then combined to create an overall ranking for each nursing home on a one to five star scale.

Rating San Diego Area Nursing Homes
A search of the database for nursing homes within a 25 mile radius of San Diego reveals that, out of the 59 nursing homes identified, 22 received overall ratings of four or five stars. An additional 19 nursing homes received three star ratings. The remaining 18 nursing homes received one or two stars.

San Diego area nursing homes are made up of 10 not-for-profit or government run nursing homes, with the remaining facilities being run for-profit. Overall, the for-profit nursing homes performed poorly compared with the not-for-profit or government run facilities. All of the nursing homes that received a one star rating are run for-profit. In addition, of those nursing homes receiving two stars, only one was a not-for-profit nursing home. USA Today reports that not-for-profit nursing homes received higher overall ratings than for-profit nursing homes under the rating system. As a result, the performance of San Diego for-profit nursing homes compared to not-for-profit nursing homes parallels the national results.

How to Use the Rating System
Those looking for a nursing home for themselves or a loved one should not rely solely on this new rating system. Instead, the ratings can provide a starting point to identify some possible facilities.

Choosing a nursing home in an area close to a person’s family and friends often improves the quality of an individual’s experience in a nursing home. With that in mind, the database can also be used to locate nursing homes in a specific area. You should always visit a nursing home to determine whether it will meet the resident’s needs and ensure that the facility provides the proper quality of care for each of its residents.

With complaints against California nursing homes to the California Department of Public Health increasing from 5,742 in 2004 to 6,950 in 2008, the importance of researching a nursing home continues to be an important part of ensuring proper elder care.

Thank you for reading my blog. If you have a question or comment, feel free to respond to this posting, but keep in mind your response will not be confidential. If you or a loved one have been the victim of abuse, negligence, or neglect by a nursing home, contact a qualified elder law attorney to find out your legal rights and options. You can also contact me to discuss your matter confidentially.